Thread: Bird or Magic
View Single Post

Old 07-05-2007, 06:54 AM   #9 (permalink)
kflo
All-Star
 
Join Date: Jun 2002
Posts: 8,334
Credits: 24,562.83
Rep Power: 3127428 kflo has a reputation beyond repute kflo has a reputation beyond repute kflo has a reputation beyond repute kflo has a reputation beyond repute kflo has a reputation beyond repute kflo has a reputation beyond repute kflo has a reputation beyond repute kflo has a reputation beyond repute kflo has a reputation beyond repute kflo has a reputation beyond repute kflo has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Bird or Magic

mvps - bird 3, magic 3
1st team all-nba - bird 9, magic 9
2nd team all-nba - bird 1, magic 1
2nd team all-defense - bird 3, magic 0
titles - bird 3, magic 5
finals mvp - bird 2, magic 3
top 2 mvp - bird 7, magic 5
games played - bird 897, magic 906
career PER - bird 23.5, magic 24.1
peak PER - bird 27.8, magic 27.0
top 3 PER - bird 5, magic 3

bird's mvp placing from his rookie season until his back surgery - 4th, 2nd, 2nd, 2nd, 1st, 1st, 1st, 3rd, 2nd.

both guys just had the ability to provide whatever their teams needed. magic's numbers and mvp placings are somewhat depressed because he simply did what was necessary for his team. and deferring to kareem and playing a more passive scoring role was best for his team through the middle of his career. only thing separating the 2 is personal preference. magic ended his career stronger, but bird started his career stronger (save for 1 legendary game).
kflo is offline   Reply With Quote