View Single Post

Old 12-24-2007, 09:55 PM   #18 (permalink)
Jordan23Forever
6th Man
 
Join Date: May 2005
Posts: 374
Credits: 4,149.97
Rep Power: 431160 Jordan23Forever has a reputation beyond repute Jordan23Forever has a reputation beyond repute Jordan23Forever has a reputation beyond repute Jordan23Forever has a reputation beyond repute Jordan23Forever has a reputation beyond repute Jordan23Forever has a reputation beyond repute Jordan23Forever has a reputation beyond repute Jordan23Forever has a reputation beyond repute Jordan23Forever has a reputation beyond repute Jordan23Forever has a reputation beyond repute Jordan23Forever has a reputation beyond repute
Re: If MJ comes back today......

Quote:
Originally Posted by luther View Post
I've just now revisited that season. He is probably around the top 20 from that year. I wouldn't say he was within the top dozen, but in the 20-25 range, yes. (Some of it depends on what you might need or want: Ben Wallace was getting 7.6 ppg, 13 rpg and 3.5 bpg, so where does that rank him?) But yes, I will give you top 20-25.

I won't change my original statement about "elite," though, because to me elite are the best. They are guys who, at their positions, are clearly superior.
Like I said initially, it depends on how you define "elite." To me, he was top 20 certainly in 2002, and top 25 in 2003. That's in the top 6-8% of the players in the NBA. But no, I agree that he wasn't top 10 in any of those seasons, nor was he the best at his position or for wing players in general.
Jordan23Forever is offline   Reply With Quote