Austin Kent

My ideal situation would be we get Michael Finley, because the stupid Canadian in me wants Jalen Rose to stay in Toronto. Contrary to popular opinion we need Rose's presence to get us through the struggles, or to at least help us start getting on the right track. I wouldn't mind having Finley though instead of Rose. Rose would be better off the bench offensively but there is something about Mike Finley that reaks of Antonio McDyess all over again.

__________________
HoopsAddict.com

The Enigma

That’s because the Pistons have no one on one players. Every one of the Pistons players succeeds in the flow of the structured offence. The only player who has anything even resembling a one on one game is Billups (and you certainly do not want that from your PG).

Note: Even his one on one play is more for himself then others. He is not a drive and dish PG and he has yet to show the ability to collapse opposing defenses with penetration (and pitch).

As one of your starters I would agree but as a 6th man selfishness (confidence in ones offensive ability) is a plus. Most prolific 6th men play a selfish game (both Corliss and Vinnie "the Microwave" Johnson can be considered selfish type players out for their points).

Note: I find the notion of Rose being selfish and cancerous to be overstated.

What Rose brings is more needed on this particular Pistons team then what Finley brings IMO. He is a superior ball handler and one on one player (both off the dribble and in the post). He is a better passer as well.

-------

With a bench that cannot score consistently and a starting SF prone to disappearing (offensively) in big games perhaps a selfish type player (off the bench) would create a nice change of pace. A player on the wing that you can give the ball to and say, "give me points" (for both himself and others) is a luxury that the Pistons do not have.

Ginobli does it for the Spurs and Rose can do it (though in a different way) for the Pistons.


...13 points in 30 minutes from Rose would do wonders for the Pistons bench.

__________________
Don’t believe the hype...


(Keep all in question for all is in C.L.U.E.)

Midnight_Marauder

You know the more I think about this.....I dont see Rose or Finley coming here....would they accept being a bench player getting like 15 minutes a game? Would Rose want to come back to Michigan this close after the whole fab 5 fiasco went down? I dunno

__________________
Old School Hip Hop Heads....old school will never die (pm me with your favorite pre 1996 album to join)
-Reisedogg "Midnight Marauders", StephenJackson "Tupacalypse Now", thug_immortal8 "Tupacalypse Now", Budweiser Boy "The Infamous", realbullsfaninLA "Critical Beatdown", PhillyPhanatic "The Mecca and the Soul Brother", Volcom "The Main Ingredient", MAS RipCity "Ready to Die", GeorgiaSports "ATLiens", Interloper "Liquid Swords", DaUnbreakableKinG "The Chronic", Premier "It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back", Pay Ton "It Takes A Nation of Millions To Hold Us Back", sMaKDiSDoWn "Illmatic", O2K "Paid In Full", Plastic Man "Mr. Hood", Tron "It Was Written", Ron Mexico "The Chronic", Nevus "The Low End Theory", BenDengGo "Doggystyle", nikebasketball "Enter The 36 Chambers", JRose5 "Straight Outta Compton", ghiman "Raising Hell", Starbury03 "KRS-ONE", Rizzah "Illmatic", blueeclipse "Illadelph Halflife", BlayZa "House of Pain", DaBigTicketKG21 "Doggystyle", BizzyRipsta "E. 1999 Eternal", Teezy "Eazy Does It" Jamel Irief "Enter the Wu" atcq1989 "The Low End Theory", Vinsanity "Me Against The World", The Krakken "Illmatic", Mecca "Strictly Business", AJM "Regulate...G Funk Era", vigilante "lifestylez ov da poor and dangerous", Go DJ! "Raising Hell", PaCeRhOLiC "Illmatic", shookem "Black Sunday", HearToTemptYou "Hustlers Convention", sliccat "Liquid Swords",RedsDrunk "Enter the Wu", PlaygroundLegend "Liquid Swords", LegoHat "Return of the Boom Bap", bruindre 'Life Is....Too $hort",T.Shock "Illmatic", ClippersRuleLA "Illmatic"

The Enigma

He could easily register 30 at the 2 and 3 alone.

Hamilton (34), Rose (14)
Prince (32), Rose (16)

...His ability to play effective minutes at the point is a potential mismatch too enticing to pass up IMO.

__________________
Don’t believe the hype...


(Keep all in question for all is in C.L.U.E.)

The Enigma

There are roughly 30 minutes available for either one of them and a potential starting spot if Prince somehow manages to reassume the role of curious George.

For some reason I simply do not see Finley accepting such a role. Not when there are other contenders (Houston, Indiana) capable of offering a starting spot for his services.

With Rose however I sense a chance (due to his ties to the area).

__________________
Don’t believe the hype...


(Keep all in question for all is in C.L.U.E.)

DetBNyce

I think Rose is a great fit just to be clear, but he still has to walk that fine line between beng selfish in a good way and just jacking up shots. Maybe a winning situation, some vets in his ear, and hopefully LB can all work together to keep him in the right direction.

I'm a mismatch guy so I like the fact that he can create a lot of those and after thinking about it I think I'd rather have him over Finley just because he's probaly a more realistic choice and on his versatility alone.