wichmae

So what youre saying is your offer would have beat Babel, MKG, Sessions and four firsts for Davis. Thats really what this is all boiling down too.

__________________
FRSL Houston Rockets
The League Nuggets

awaywehappened

Naw lol.
I find it really funny when GM's look at it that way.
If I criticize a trade because I personally don't like it, it's because I'm jealous.



My offer was a lowball in the first place...
I'm just saying I think you would've been better keeping Davis...

MKG is a great young player, but Davis has far more impact used correctly.
Babel is nothing but a stash guy.
Sessions is old and overpaid, basically an expiring.
Of the four firsts, they're all mid-late.

Your team, not mine.

*shrugs*

__________________

JerryWest

I got Cosic pick 9. Two of my starters next year will be Nikos Mabrokopolis who I picked 28 and is one of the better PGs in entire sim, Betis pick 15 (who is best big of last draft imo).

Mid to late 1sts aren't guaranteed talent. But there are some really good players bc omer and shmip usually balanced draft classes where there aren't a lot of clear stars after the first 3 picks. A lot of this will depend on wichmae's drafting ability though.

don't think anyone has offered wichmae anything close to what I did in giving my two best players + 2 unprotected 1sts

__________________
KVBL Basketball Sim, Los Angeles Lakers

FRSL, Los Angeles Lakers
Season 2 Champs (64-18), Season 4 Champs (66-16), Season 5 Champs (72-10)

awaywehappened

Not everyone drafts as well as you, or can put together a winning team as efficiently as you.

__________________

JerryWest

Think some of you are underrating MKG. MKG at 25 has already been 3x all nba player and has SG eligiblity, he's more valuable than anyone on entire Hawks team. Easily would be best player for half the teams in the league of extra reb he brings at SG position where I played him for two of my titles.

His defensive and reb impact is underrated when you consider I was only team to be 2-0 vs Pacers this year even though I'm doing badly. That was pretty much bc of MKG shutting down onasis.

__________________
KVBL Basketball Sim, Los Angeles Lakers

FRSL, Los Angeles Lakers
Season 2 Champs (64-18), Season 4 Champs (66-16), Season 5 Champs (72-10)

BlakeJesus

MKG's value in relation to a roster that's not involved in this trade is completely irrelevant and is clearly a troll pot shot attempt by you. I see this as you half-assedly trying to defend the trade on behalf of a new owner that you know you just got the best of.

This feels like you're just talking to talk at this point, because you are clearly avoiding the actual topic of discussion. Nobody has said MKG is without value, it's clear he is a nice player. That being said, it doesn't matter how you view him in the pantheon of players, what matters is right here in this deal where he was the center piece that netted in return one of the single best players in the sim.

It's not an all time screw up for the Mavs, but the value clearly favors one side.

__________________

Gary23

Nugent!

JerryWest

I like Davis, otherwise I wouldn't have offered so much for him. But fact that you ignore how good MKG is just means to me you are envious that I got him and you probably didn't because you wouldn't offer anything half as good as what I did bc you lowball too much on your offers.

__________________
KVBL Basketball Sim, Los Angeles Lakers

FRSL, Los Angeles Lakers
Season 2 Champs (64-18), Season 4 Champs (66-16), Season 5 Champs (72-10)

BlakeJesus

I didn't send an offer for him, I didn't even realize he was available. Again making random assumptions with no basis to them (even included another poor attempt at a pot shot), at least you're consistent.

MKG is not even in the same ballpark in terms of talent compared to Anthony Davis, and you clearly have no leg to stand on in an argument the other way considering you just traded MKG AND assets to get Davis.

__________________

Smath

just to make this clear , the new Mavs GM is very active and wana learn , he advises with me on almost every move he makes.

and I told him this trade is good for him , so did Omer , so he clearly doesn't lose here like you guys think he did ~_~

MKG is soooo under-rated omg.

__________________
KVBL/FRSL - Miami Heat GM

BlakeJesus

__________________

kreutz35

As someone who still regrets giving up MKG, I completely agree. Despite what you're all saying, I still don't see this as a bad deal for the Mavs. They're rebuilding. Yeah, they give up a very good player, but they gain another very good (and still only 25) player, a solid veteran, and 2 unprotected firsts. I understand that Davis is a beast, but this is still, in no way, a bad deal for a rebuilding Mavs team.

__________________

awaywehappened

Those picks don't have much value at all.

__________________

shmip

I dont understand how u can say that..

__________________

FRSL Commissioner,Detroit "Bad Boys" Pistons GM

kreutz35

me either. I know that Kenneth is a great GM, but you're acting like he's the second coming or something. Even for a great GM, it take more then one season to go from where he is to championship caliber.

__________________