The One

I did not think I'll see the day where Smush is as hated as Atkins.

But at this time, if I had to choose, I'd pick Atkins right now because at least every game for the Lakers he looked like he wanted to be there and his only mishap ws when he called Kobe the GM. We can't count how many times Smush has underminded Phil in public and Alienated himself from the team during mood swings. Smush just looks ungratefull.

__________________

nguyen_milan

How about no one? I want another PG

__________________
Kobe Bryant:

Theonee

Atleast Atkins can hit open shots.

Bartholomew Hunt

Atkins was so horrible defensively, that he makes Smush look like a below-average defender rather than completely awful like he really is. This is really close though. I think it's sad for the organization that both have been fulltime starters for the Lakers. Really sad.

Basel57

If I had to choose, I would choose neither and play 4-on-5.

__________________

Bleeding purple & gold...

Cris

Option C

__________________

CubanLaker

Atkins or Smush??


I just threw up a little in my mouth..

__________________

Rumble, young man, rumble...

Eternal

Like Basel said 4 on 5.

Shaolin

Really tho.

FWIW, Atkins wasn't really hated.

Ruff Draft

I think i'd take Chucky's offensive game, and lack of defense over Smush's lack of both.

__________________
"I'm not just saying we are going to do it my way, I'm just saying we are going to do it the Championship Way."
-Michael Curry

2008-2009 Detroit Pistons
PG: Allen Iverson, Rodney Stuckey, Will Bynum
SG: Rip Hamilton, Arron Afflalo
SF: Tayshaun Prince, Walter Herrmann, Walter Sharpe
PF: Kwame Brown, Jason Maxiell, Amir Johnson
C: Rasheed Wallace

Drewbs

Smush is a better player than Atkins, but I take Atkins simply because you know what you're going to get from him. Smush however, is never dependable.

__________________
The Ray and May, "Your newest Charlotte Bobcats," Fan Club

1. Drewbs 2. Baron McGrady 3. Vigilante 4. Bruno34115 4. Bkbballer16 5. -D! 6. Sir Patchwork 7. FanOfAll8472 8. Pistolballer 9.TiMVP2 10. TAllen4211. HallOfFamer 12. WhoDaBest23 13. Ron_Artest9131 14. Rynobot 15. Bron_Melo_ROY 16. GoDWade 17. Charlotte_______ 18. Nutmeged3 19. KobeBryant08 20. dwade321. BlueBaron 22. Jeremias 23. endora60 24.pmac34 25.Knick_Killer31 26.You?

PM to join

Serg LeMagnifique

I wouldn't take either one. How about Sasha and Farmar.

KDOS

Smush is more talented than Atkins, he just needs some guide to help him achieve and reach his potential, so far Phil Jackson has been reaching but Smush cant seem to get over that hump.


Parker was solid for the most part last season, people were jumping for joy earlier on because he was such a great addition and the Lakers are only paying him water boy salary. No one in this league thought he could be a part of a 12 man roster, much more start in it. Parker helped his team reached the playoffs last year, and he was monumental in helping LA win that game 4. Parker has contributed more than Atkins did as a Laker. I cant say anything nice to Chucky, because he's such a DBAG lol, I think my judgement is clouded by my hate, eversince he made that, "ask Kobe, he's the GM" remark.


In reality though, its pathetic that it all somes down to this, choosing who was a better guard, Smush or Chucky for this storied franchise.

West44

<P> </P>
<P>&nbsp;</P>
<P>lmfao <IMG alt=0 src="http://www.basketballboards.net/forum/images/smilies/laugh.gif" border=0 smilieid="22"> </P>