[bigbabyjesus]

Yeah I know either of them have even played an NBA game, but who would you rather have on your team, for now, and for the future?


uhh.. damnit.. could a mod add a poll to this thread? thanks.

[Pan Mengtu]

Hmm... let's see.... Livingston is already way better than Telfair.... has been called the possible steal of the draft... has more upside...... and Telfair isn't even 6 foot tall.. tough one.....

[Spriggan]

Originally posted by Pan Mengtu!
Hmm... let's see.... Livingston is already way better than Telfair.... has been called the possible steal of the draft... has more upside...... and Telfair isn't even 6 foot tall.. tough one.....

telfair probably weighs more than livingston.

[texan]

Livingston. But both of em will be good.

[WhoDaBest23]

Telfair and Livingston will both be good players for years to come and I like both of them, but I'll go with Telfair.

[texan]

Originally posted by WhoDaBest23!
Telfair and Livingston will both be good players for years to come and I like both of them, but I'll go with Telfair.

why so? cuz you have telfair?

[JNice]

I take Livingston, but its only a guess. Both guys have the possibility of being bigtime busts.

[Blazer Freak]

It's a hard one. I personally think that Livingston will be a Penny Hardaway, and Telfair is a Pure PG, who I personally think in 1-2 years will be able to start. If I wanted a PG I'd pick Telfair. Again I think Shaun will turn into an 2/3.

BFreak.

Also, dont get me wrong, I don't think Shaun is bad, I'd just rather have Telfair as my PG.

[WhoDaBest23]

Originally posted by texan!


why so? cuz you have telfair?

Well yeah that has something to do with it. But I've always thought Telfair's gonna turn out to be a special player ever since I read about him blowing up in high school. Not to take anything away from Livingston, but I don't know, I just have a good hunch about Telfair.

[roastedtoaster]

Livingston. Bigger, more upside. better feel for the game. Telfair....was only drafted as high as he was because of Nike market appeal. Undersized. Poor shot. Poor shooting mechanics. Can make the flashy pass.....can he make the solid pass? in terms of the mighty mites....he could be a damon stoudemire. I think jameer will end up being the better player in the end.....and i dont think jameer will come close to being an elite player.

but hey, its all opinion. and thats why they have offseasons. we'll see which one developes themself better. should be interesting.

[Pan Mengtu]

You have it completely wrong. Telfair is the one who wants to be a combo guard. Have you seen his FGA from high school? I realize he was the best player on his team and all, but good god he shot nonstop. He'll be like Marbury, but shorter, less athletic and a worse shooter. And not nearly as good. Livingston, on the other hand, has been compared to Magic in his basketball IQ is already through the roof, he's big, sure, but he's a real PG.