Quote:
|
Originally Posted by shookem
So destroy a division winning team by trading a young All Star (starter!) and "whatever else" for a guy who hasn't played a NBA game?
Nah.
|
ill try to explain my thoughts a little better now that i have a little time to do so.
1) a division winning team, in my opinion, is not really something great. youve got to considere that we won the worst division in the league, and that we were one-and-done in the playoffs. now, as a fan, i would like my team to be a title contender, not a playoff contender. i must admit im not very high on bosh so obviously im not really fair, but i think his playoffs showed that he might just not have that killer instinct that all champions have.
2)the all star starter: this gets a little trickier. its all a matter of potential, so what im saying now might make no sense whatsoever a couple years from now.
imagine you were dallas after dirk's first year (stats worse than bargnanis, worse defense...). if they told you you could get a Zo mourning (all star player back then?) would you have traded dirk?
there was no way you could know dirk was going to be so great, but the dallas management believed so, and they got it right.
same situation here. if bargnani and oden turn out to be champions there is no need for a bosh, which i dont think will become as good as the other two fellas.
3)the trade does make sense to portland if they believe aldridge is a good player because they could play bosh at the 4 and aldridge at the 5 (both their natural positions) and also get other good players from the trade.
4) lets make clear that these are MY thoughts and are based solely on MY evaluations. as said earlier, i might be COMPLETELY WRONG with my low opinion on bosh and with my high hopes on bargs. im not even trying to say that your point does not make sense because it does. there is a much bigger chance that your opinion will eventually turn out better than my bet.