I agree with these rankings. However, I believe the breakthrough play of Amare was key in the acceptance of LeBron as a credible player outta HS. Who woulda believed if Amare hadn't set the example?Originally posted by <b>The OUTLAW</b>!
Amare played on a much better team than Lebron.Originally posted by <b>RebelSun</b>!
1.) LeBron - unbeliebable play from HS guard
2.) Carmelo - played awesome as well as a rookie
3.) Amare - had the best out-of-HS rookie year ever...until this year.
Your comments about Camby is ridiculous.Originally posted by <b>John The Cool Kid</b>!
I dont think Miller, Camby, or any of the guys you listed are as good as Carmelo. Andre Miller is the only one thats debatable really. Miller is a good passer, but hes no Jkidd. Infact he averages 3 less assists a game, which is about the same difference between Miller and Melos assists numbers. Camby is nowhere near Wallace, he barely averages 10 rebounds a game(actually he doesnt, hes at 9.9)
Exactly...:yes: BigAmare will defend any Suns player to the nth degree without logic for the most part. Most people will have Amare at 3rd without a doubt and for good reason. BigAmare came on the Portland board and said Z-Bo did not deserve an all-star nod even though he gets 21 and 11 each night. Zach had good numbers this year but there are a lot of very good players in the west. But Marion and Amare are better players than Zach no matter what according to the BigAmare. Is this guy a hoot or joke or what?Originally posted by <b>John The Cool Kid</b>!
If the case is closed, its for the opposite of what you think. Its no coincedence that every single person who voted in this thread has Amare at 3rd.