Elton Brand is a true power forward he posts up and gets rebounds wat a pf is supposed to do. while u have Twan a PF with a guards minds meaning hes a 3 point shooter 1st the he might post u up. I would take Brand without even thinkin about it.
I would go with Brand, I perfer a post player that plays in the post... Look at how Walker's career has gone... he has been mentioned in many trade rumors due to the fact his act is tough to do... before this year, was he even close to these stats? And when the Celtics lose it's cause of his game. While Brand puts up similar numbers... but he hardly gets criticized for being the reasons why the Clippers and Bulls haven't won with him.
As a PF I gotta go with Brand because he does the things a PF is supposed to do. Ive always considered Walker a SF playing PF just because Paul Pierce is the better SF. Walker shoots under 40% and as far as Im concerned that unnaceptable. He is a good 2nd option scorer, I honestly think he's one of the more over rated stars in the league, but he still puts up good numbers.
Your saying Walker has to share the ball with pierce but Brand has to share with Odom Richardson Mcginnis Miles Kandi and that sg Patskowski (or something) and yes I know some of those people are gone now but thats who played with Brand last year.
Whens the last time you saw Walker leading in RBS or BLKS? That what a PF does. Walker is a sf playing pf so the better pf is Brand. As for whos the better player is a different arguement.