[shookem]

I kinda though he'd at least be second or third place in ROY voting....

 

[superdude211]

Agreed no way he should have finished 5th. Mabey the fact the he plays in Canada has something to do with it

 

[shookem]

I dunno Eric Hinskie won it. I think everyone just buys into the hype of the A's farm system.

 

[spinz]

as posted in the thread of this forum:

i think Chacin got cheated a little here...not to undermine Street's rookie campaign, but Chacin was a starter in a rotation where he was the leader for much of the second half (especially after our ACE's injury)...he also had a pretty good season

TOR 13w 9l 3.72era 203.0 ip 121 so

glad to see two first place votes, but he should have either been in the top three if not rookie of the year...

 

[NeoSamurai]

i wouldve placed him 4th...the problem with his season was that he fizzled out late in the season and his best perfromances were in the start...

plus he playing in a smaller baseball market that wont get as much media attention...

i'd probably have the voting: Street, Cano, Iguchi, Chacin...