Professional and College Basketball Forums banner

is artest a better player then peja?

813 Views 24 Replies 16 Participants Last post by  VeN
i think so. if pejas shot isnt falling he doesnt really do anything else. his rebounding is pretty good and his defense isnt terrible but hes afraid of contact and doesnt post up as much as he should. what do you guys think? and if he leaves after this season is over then you basically traded ron for nothing when you could have had corey maggete who is also better then peja.
1 - 20 of 25 Posts
Artest easily. No questions or arguments needed.
Pacers Fan said:
Artest easily. No questions or arguments needed.
Artest is definetly better overall player then Peja, but still Peja was the best we could have gotten in return for Artest.

Corey Maggatte wasn't an anwser, the guy gets hurt alot and complains way too much, he wouldn't have fit well with Larry Bird and Rick Carlisle. He complains alot and wants to run the team, and not be part of the team, and isn't that what got Artest in trouble in Indy???

I'm very happy with Peja as a return for Artest, even if he walks. I'm sure Bird will try to sign and trade him or even look into keeping him, so it won't just be Artest for a rent-a-player.
Pacers Fan said:
Artest easily. No questions or arguments needed.
Co-sign.
Yup....And so is Maggette. And so is Big Al.
JayRedd said:
Yup....And so is Maggette. And so is Big Al.
Wrong, on both players. Like i said about Maggette, i wouldn't want him anywhere near Indianapolis. The guy is a team cancer and wouldn't work well with a team like the Pacers, and he definetly wouldn't be good with Bird or Carlisle. I'd take Peja over him anyday, and i'd take Peja over Harrington as well. Although, i was a big fan of Harrington when he was here, but we just needed something different.
MillerTime said:
Wrong, on both players. Like i said about Maggette, i wouldn't want him anywhere near Indianapolis. The guy is a team cancer and wouldn't work well with a team like the Pacers, and he definetly wouldn't be good with Bird or Carlisle. I'd take Peja over him anyday, and i'd take Peja over Harrington as well. Although, i was a big fan of Harrington when he was here, but we just needed something different.
Agreed. I love how everyone is judging Peja when he has barely had the opportunity to feed off of JO. Just silly.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
StephenJackson said:
Agreed. I love how everyone is judging Peja when he has barely had the opportunity to feed off of JO. Just silly.
I've seen some nice glimpses... :cheers:

BTW - I thought JO was passing quite well to everyone against MIA...

I'ld like to keep Peja... he brings a nice deminsion to our team...

Artest is a better player... but Peja is overall the better choice for Indy... no explanations needed... I believe we all know why...
JayRedd said:
Yup....And so is Maggette. And so is Big Al.
No way.
Artest said:
i think so. if pejas shot isnt falling he doesnt really do anything else. his rebounding is pretty good and his defense isnt terrible but hes afraid of contact and doesnt post up as much as he should. what do you guys think? and if he leaves after this season is over then you basically traded ron for nothing when you could have had corey maggete who is also better then peja.
For the last time!!!! One of the best front offices in all of professional sports is not going to trade a top-25 player for a fringe All-Star and then let him walk for nothing. Worst-case scenario is a sign-and-trade. Man, how many times will I have to freakin' say this. :curse:
Artest is more talented but I wouldn't say he is better player. Good players don't **** up two seasones in row and then state that they don't give a **** about it.
Maggs is in fact milder version of Artest thinks he is better then he is and is injury prone, Al can't play sf so haveing him could mean something like... JO at C and Harrison on bench - don't like it...
Petja isn't useless when hes of he still cares, passes, hustles, plays ok defense, rebounds (very well). So he brings everithing else on table and doesn't kill our offense (like J-Sax or some other guys seems to do when they are off) b) we have Danny.
Another thing how often is Petja off or jacking up? Not often, in fact he is our most consistant shooter since Reggie. If someone has problem with hes shooting and shot selection then I guess he hasn't seen Jamaal,Fred, S-JAX, Johnson... playing... Petja is far more efficent shooter then any of them. For example Petja shoots with .455% and Ferd .42%, S-Jax .411% and the list goes on. So what is what we don't have and another selfis wing would give us instead of Petja?
See less See more
absolutebest said:
For the last time!!!! One of the best front offices in all of professional sports is not going to trade a top-25 player for a fringe All-Star and then let him walk for nothing. Worst-case scenario is a sign-and-trade. Man, how many times will I have to freakin' say this. :curse:
You're wrong there. Worst case scenario is we extend Peja for 5 years/$70 million. Then it's five more years of the mediocre, almost Finals contending style NBA basketball us Pacer fans have grown to love so much. YEEE-HAAWWW!!! :rolleyes:

And for the record, how is Maggette a team cancer? I know he has injury problems, but when healthy, he is an equally good scorer to Peja, a head and shoulder better defender, equal rebounder, better assist guy, plus he's two years younger, and over the next three years, he's will make $7.3 mil, $7.8 mil and $8.4 mil each season, which is somewhere close to half what Peja will be making during that same time. You can't ignore salaries here. Bird and Walsh seemed to see it similarly and seemed more than happy to acquire Maggette before looking into the severity of his foot injury. From where they sit, I can see why they wouldn't wanna roll the dice on an injury of that nature (Bird saw both Walton and McHale's foot problems first hand), but they recognized the talent and even if you do prefer Peja's game, the difference is marginal.

As for Al Harrington, I'll take the 26-year-old, 6'10, athletic phenom who can play multiple positions , create a mismatch for almost any forward in this league (not to mention his own shot. How many times have I heard you guys complain that Peja doesn't get the ball at the end of games. Great players go get the ball, not wait to get it) and who is just coming into his own in averaging 18/7/3 over the past two years instead of the aging (nearly 29. He'll be 34/35 years old when we're paying him $16 or $17 mil in the final year of a max deal), best-days-behind him, 6'10 jump shooter from Europe.

Give me youth and defense. I'm pretty sure Rick Carlisle would agree.
See less See more
JayRedd said:
You're wrong there. Worst case scenario is we extend Peja for 5 years/$70 million. Then it's five more years of the mediocre, almost Finals contending style NBA basketball us Pacer fans have grown to love so much. YEEE-HAAWWW!!! :rolleyes:

And for the record, how is Maggette a team cancer? I know he has injury problems, but when healthy, he is an equally good scorer to Peja, a head and shoulder better defender, equal rebounder, better assist guy, plus he's two years younger, and over the next three years, he's will make $7.3 mil, $7.8 mil and $8.4 mil each season, which is somewhere close to half what Peja will be making during that same time. You can't ignore salaries here. Bird and Walsh seemed to see it similarly and seemed more than happy to acquire Maggette before looking into the severity of his foot injury. From where they sit, I can see why they wouldn't wanna roll the dice on an injury of that nature (Bird saw both Walton and McHale's foot problems first hand), but they recognized the talent and even if you do prefer Peja's game, the difference is marginal.

As for Al Harrington, I'll take the 26-year-old, 6'10, athletic phenom who can play multiple positions , create a mismatch for almost any forward in this league (not to mention his own shot. How many times have I heard you guys complain that Peja doesn't get the ball at the end of games. Great players go get the ball, not wait to get it) and who is just coming into his own in averaging 18/7/3 over the past two years instead of the aging (nearly 29. He'll be 34/35 years old when we're paying him $16 or $17 mil in the final year of a max deal), best-days-behind him, 6'10 jump shooter from Europe.

Give me youth and defense. I'm pretty sure Rick Carlisle would agree.
Maybe you will get your wish and we'll send Jamaal Tinsley and Peja to Atlanta for Al and something. However, I highly doubt it. I think a trade with someone like Memphis or Charlotte is more likely.

What do you guys think of something like Gerald Wallace and Brevin Knight for Peja and Tinsley? They would get younger (Knight is like 31), a veteran PG to back up Felton, and a star player that puts people in the seats, plus some much needed scoring. We would get a steady, pass-first PG that doesn't turn the ball over and plays great defense. Plus, we would get an ultra-athletic swingman that plays some serious defense. Get me on the phone with Bernie Bickerstaff. I know that they will want to start Felton next year, so this isn't far-fetched at all. At least to me it isn't. Thoughts?
JayRedd said:
You're wrong there. Worst case scenario is we extend Peja for 5 years/$70 million. Then it's five more years of the mediocre, almost Finals contending style NBA basketball us Pacer fans have grown to love so much. YEEE-HAAWWW!!! :rolleyes:

And for the record, how is Maggette a team cancer? I know he has injury problems, but when healthy, he is an equally good scorer to Peja, a head and shoulder better defender, equal rebounder, better assist guy, plus he's two years younger, and over the next three years, he's will make $7.3 mil, $7.8 mil and $8.4 mil each season, which is somewhere close to half what Peja will be making during that same time. You can't ignore salaries here. Bird and Walsh seemed to see it similarly and seemed more than happy to acquire Maggette before looking into the severity of his foot injury. From where they sit, I can see why they wouldn't wanna roll the dice on an injury of that nature (Bird saw both Walton and McHale's foot problems first hand), but they recognized the talent and even if you do prefer Peja's game, the difference is marginal.

As for Al Harrington, I'll take the 26-year-old, 6'10, athletic phenom who can play multiple positions , create a mismatch for almost any forward in this league (not to mention his own shot. How many times have I heard you guys complain that Peja doesn't get the ball at the end of games. Great players go get the ball, not wait to get it) and who is just coming into his own in averaging 18/7/3 over the past two years instead of the aging (nearly 29. He'll be 34/35 years old when we're paying him $16 or $17 mil in the final year of a max deal), best-days-behind him, 6'10 jump shooter from Europe.

Give me youth and defense. I'm pretty sure Rick Carlisle would agree.
Be real Bird won't sign Petja for mx deal he would a) do sign and trade b) let him walk but I don't see it happening.

Al will be hore expensive than Petja. Isn't abel to guard sf well (weight, other issues) and isn't better mismach then Petja.

Maggs isn't clearly better defender is athletic freak and relies on it fully and has serious issues with injuries. He is complaining a lot. Example he has problem comeing of bench, he is claiming he is 100% fine and should start but hes shot is off and he need time to overcome stamina problems - this is Clipper reality. I agree he works hard and is really talented but he is more sselfiss (les team player/passer then Petja), he is worse rebounder and hes shot is so-so. I agree if uninjured he contract is fine but if it runs up you have to overpay him (might not be the case with Petja). I agree he might be good fit since he is super quick and superb finisher=gets to the lane a lot. I'd say hes quickness is comperable to Kobe people just don't see it since hes handle isn't that good. He is also hard worker but he does have much bigger ego and he does whine at times, also has injury problems. That means he would be bigger risk. All in all Petja has worked out fine. So whats the problem. If we get him really cheaply resign I will be really happy and I don't see him getting monster contract.
See less See more
Artest is a walking matchup problem...

He's too strong for all 3's, and he's too quick for a 4

Great defender, and an underrated & improving offensive player.

No question he's better than Peja
Shaq_Diesel said:
Artest is a walking matchup problem...

He's too strong for all 3's, and he's too quick for a 4

Great defender, and an underrated & improving offensive player.

No question he's better than Peja
So? He also tends to shoot something in lins 4-18 at times lately he wanted to be first opinion but I am not sure wether he is good enough especially if you have pf like JO. Also he seems to be psychopath, has huge ego and isn't smart guy. So he is better talent but not teamate/team player in long run (to much trouble and risk). For example D. Miles has more talent than most of sf's too but talent dosn't =good player.
Guys , how you assess talent ? Because peja is gifted. He is maybe the best shooter in the world. Ok Artest plays good defence but you need talent to play defence ? No, you need quick feet and power in your body.Many players can play good defence but how many can you bring in your mind with the talent of peja in shooting ? maybe Artest is better overall but i think peja has the talent...and indiana has to exploit it...
Well... Like I said... Peja is opting out, as the Kings knew he would have. I'm sure the Pacers organization knew it as well. I think this team never had Peja in it's future, and [controversial] only traded for Peja because they want to completely re-do the team and probably felt the fans would be happy by at least getting something for Ron even the organization probably wanted to just get rid of Ron and start over. Knowing Peja would in all likelyhood opt out, they signed him, thus appeasing the fans by getting the best player they could have gotten, then be rid of him at the end of the season, yet everyone would blame Peja for leaving when it was really the Pacers that wanted it to happen in the first place[/end] *I think it's a good move by the Pacers btw*
1 - 20 of 25 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top