[Nikos]

Last playoffs seem to be Ray Allens breakout time. He went on a rampage and probably played the best ball of his career. Many considered him to be a top 3-4 SG.

Do you think he still is a great SG in this league even after the dissapointing run of Milwakee this season??

 

[HEATLUNATIC]

NO WAY IN HELL is Ray Allen a top 5 SG,his D is way to DAMN suspect!:uhoh:

1 - T-Mac
2 - Iverson
3 - Pierce
4 - Kobe
5 - Vince
6 - Finley
7 - Stack

Hes in the top 10,but NOT above these ballers,:no:!

 

[jvanbusk]

Ray Allen is still one heck of a player. He's an exceptionable player but shooting guard in the NBA is very deep with great players. If I had to rate them it would be:

1. Kobe Bryant
2. Tracy McGrady
3. Allen Iverson
4. Vince Carter
5. Jerry Stackhouse

'He Got Game' would be either 6th or 7th, in my opinion.

 

[Crossword]

A resounding NO!

My rankings are:

1. Tracy McGrady
2. Kobe Bryant
3. Vince Carter
4. Allen Iverson
5. Michael Finley

In fact I'd also rank Stack ahead of Ray. More of a complete player.

 

[Wilt_The_Stilt]

1.Kobe
2.T-Mac
3.Pierce
4.Vince
5.Allen

I don't think that AI or Stack is that great

 

[Fordy74]

Originally posted by Wilt_The_Stilt
1.Kobe
2.T-Mac
3.Pierce
4.Vince
5.Allen

I don't think that AI or Stack is that great

no matter my personal liking of a player. I will never call anyone who wins a scoring title not that great.

 

[CoolHandLuke]

All seven of those are the top elite 2's in the league. Trying to put them in a certain order just isn't fair. Why not just call them the upper echelon?

 

[jvanbusk]

CHL,

I agree to a certain extent, but here's my feelings...

Kobe and Tracy are about equal in my opinion, but Kobe's already established himself as a winner, so he gets the nod as #1, and Tracy becomes #2. Vince, with a good year could be considered ahead of Iverson, but I really feel that the injury hindered the play of Vinsanity. This pushes Iverson to #3 and puts Vince back at #4. Jerry Stackhouse had an awesome year that put him in the top 5, and he could be ranked ahead of Vince, but he needs another great year to move up. Finley, another great player, is not as good as these five. Either is Ray Allen. Pierce, in my eyes, is a SF. That's why I ranked as I did, maybe I should have clarified with my original post.

 

[HEATLUNATIC]

I agree with the whole upper echelon thing,but Pierce just like
T-Mac/Kobe and Finley is listed as a G/F.

 

[jvanbusk]

That's true. I don't know what I was thinking. But, Kobe is a shooting guard, isn't he?

 

[HEATLUNATIC]

Yep Kobe plays G most of the time,cuz Fox/Horry play SF.

 

[SikHandlez24]

IMX Top 10 Shooting Guards...

1. Kobe Bryant Lakers
2. Tracy Mcgrady Magic
3. Paul Pierce
4. Allen Iverson Sixers
5. Vince Carter Raptors
6. Cuttino Mobley Rockets
7. Michael Finley Mavs
8. Ray Allen Bucks
9. Jerry Stackhouse Pistons
10. Richard Hamilton Wizards

 

[Ice]

Yeah definitely a top 5 sg here's my list:

Kobe
Iverson
Allen
Finley
Rip Hamilton

Although T-Mac, Vince, and Pierce are better than Allen I feel they're more of a 3 than a 2

 

[Lope31]

Originally posted by PacerMan
1. Kobe
2. Tracy
3. Pierce
4. Iverson
5. Vince

i agree :yes:

 

[Cleveland Browns]

kobe
tmac
pierce
vince(overated but still in top 5)
iverson

 

[Ray3Iverson3]

ray allen had a bad year this year he is still in the top 5 sg's tho!