[Chicago N VA]

I have been offered this trade, I am really on the fence...

Here is the trade below:

His Guys
James, Mike
Radmanovic, Vladimir

For
My Guy
Kirilenko, Andrei

Players.................................. GP- FG%- FT%- 3PTM- PTS- REB- AST- ST- BLK- TO- PF
James, Mike (G, PG-Bos)........... 39 - .401 - .824 - 66 - 433 - 126 - 181 - 50 - 2 - 63 - 82
Radmanovic, Vladimir (PF-Sea)....35 - .395 - .774 - 68 - 460 - 210 - 81 - 52 - 25 - 51 - 85





Chicago.v2004
Players .................................GP- FG%- FT%- 3PTM- PTS- REB- AST- ST- BLK- TO- PF
Kirilenko, Andrei (SF, PF-Uta)....36 - .464 - .807 - 28 - 573 - 284 - 116 - 77 - 98 - 106 - 91

Would You do this trade?

 

[SecretAgentGuy]

Originally posted by <b>Chicago N VA</b>!
I have been offered this trade, I am really on the fence...

Here is the trade below:

His Guys
James, Mike
Radmanovic, Vladimir

For
My Guy
Kirilenko, Andrei

Players.................................. GP- FG%- FT%- 3PTM- PTS- REB- AST- ST- BLK- TO- PF
James, Mike (G, PG-Bos)........... 39 - .401 - .824 - 66 - 433 - 126 - 181 - 50 - 2 - 63 - 82
Radmanovic, Vladimir (PF-Sea)....35 - .395 - .774 - 68 - 460 - 210 - 81 - 52 - 25 - 51 - 85





Chicago.v2004
Players .................................GP- FG%- FT%- 3PTM- PTS- REB- AST- ST- BLK- TO- PF
Kirilenko, Andrei (SF, PF-Uta)....36 - .464 - .807 - 28 - 573 - 284 - 116 - 77 - 98 - 106 - 91

Would You do this trade?

never

 

[PC Load Letter]

Kirilenko is a great player. In fact, he's gotta be top 10 in the league fantasy-wise. Both James and Radmanovic are good but don't put up near the numbers AK47 does. I guess in fantasy, sometimes you should go for quantity over quality, but I wouldn't even have thought this long about doing this trade. I say keep your guy.

 

[reHEATed]

kirilinko is 5th fantasy wise in the yahoo rankings..no way u do this one

 

[ace20004u]

Yeah, keep AK-47. I have Radmanovic on my fantasy team and even though he is a great player he is sometimes inconsistant stat wise and James isn't much.

 

[bullet]

U don't trade a player like AK-47!!!

Unless ofcourse u r the Bulls GM and give away Artest and Miller for nothing.

 

[Chicago N VA]

I guess I was looking at quantity (stats) versus quality (stats).

What was I thinking

Thanks for the input.

 

[Rhyder]

Unless you have a significant injury to one of your other players where you can't get a good FA off the waivers, don't do the trade. You win by having the best players at the positions, not by combining stats.

In order to go for quantity, you have to look if the second guy he is offereing improves the worst guy out of your starters more than what you are going to replace Kirilenko with. If it does, then look to see what FAs are out there that may do the same trick without having to give up your guy.

That way, you improve your team, and the guy offering up the trade does not get to improve his.

The simple rule: Never trade 2:1, unless you are the one getting the one (unless someone is doing a firesale in a rollover league)

 

[spongyfungy]

Don't even think about trading AK.

pickup a guy like keith bogans or Tinsley. DeShawn Stevenson is a good pickup as well. even brevin knight with Gilbert out a bit longer.