meru said:
My Dad was a HUGE sci-fi fan in the pre-cyberpunk days (I got the Simpsons joke when Martin runs for class president and talks about the ABCs - Asimov, something (Brenner?) and Clarke) and he swore that the best science fiction book ever written was The Mote In God's Eye by Larry Niven (one of the masters) and Jerry Pournelle. I have to say I found it pretty gripping, but that was 20 years ago.
Larry Niven is great... a bit pulpy for some (especially those of a snobby bent) but TONS of fun.
The Mote in God's Eye was a very good book, and the sequel was decent, too. The notion that there could be a civilization that was doomed to boom and collapse innumerable times is fascinating.
Niven's Known Space set of stories (including "Ringworld") was a lot of fun and a short step from a lot of Heinlein's work.
In England, the His Dark Materials trilogy by Philip Pullman is as popular as Tolkein. Anyone read it? I found the first two gripping but so depressing that I haven't got to the third one yet. It's been a play on the West End, and will be a movie(s), albeit toned down for the more religious American audience
Good books; I've read them all. I agree they're depressing... I would be interested to know what children think of it (and it's, at some level, young adult fantasy).
The daemon/soul mate idea is so cool, but the manifestation of that in a physical sense in Pullman's stories allow him to be particularly cruel.
If we're talking about great fantasy writing, though: it's ALL about George RR Martin for me. The fourth book in his Song of Fire and Ice series should be coming out this year, and I can't wait to re-read all 1800-odd pages of the first three books as soon as I read a reliable release date.
Ed O.