[KG4MVP2]

Rankings based on performance this year
1.jason kidd
2.baron davis
3.stephon marbury
4.steve francis
5.lebron james
6.sam cassell
7.mike bibby
8.steve nash
9.tony parker
10.gilbert arenas
11.jason terry
12.gary payton
13.dwayne wade
14.jason williams
15.andre miller
16.nick van exel
17.chauncey billiups
18.brent barry
19.kirk hinrich
20.jamal crawford
21.raul lopez
22.tj ford
23.carlos arroyo
24.marko jaric
25.leandro barbosa
26.steve blake
27.luke ridnour
28.chucky atkins
29.eric snow
30.earl watson
31.troy hudson
any thoughts comments????????

 

[reHEATed]

if based on this year only, Cassell should be higher

 

[catcher]

cassel should be at 3 or 4

 

[thrillhouse]

chauncey should be higher.

 

[SheriffKilla]

francis should be lower

 

[MentalPowerHouse]

Whats with all the rookies who have barely played being put infront of Eric Snow? We are talking about this year, so'd take Snow for my team any day over Ridnour, Hinrich, Ford, Barbosa etc.

Not too good of a ranking, alot of it based on rookie hype it would seem. I would still take Alvin Williams over most of those rookies.

 

[AL9045]

Well since Lebron isn't a PG anymore, if you want to be all precise and stuff, I would take him off the list. .

 

[SheriffKilla]

raul lopez over carlos arroyo????
arroyo is the best player on the jazz besides kirilenko and harping
he is their most consistent scorer IMO
and is an excellent passer has some very pretty moves
his only problem is turnovers

 

[chiuondis]

ger rid of LeBron.... bump Cassell ahead of Francis
and also bump Bibby ahead of Francis too
Crawford ahead of Hinrich

 

[Tom]

wade? not a bad list though...well thought out overall.

 

[Jmonty580]

Where's Bobby Jackson?

 

[Ezmo]

yah, just trade cassell and francis.
and hasnt arenas only played like 20 games this year, so i dont think he should be that high.

 

[AL9045]

Why is Barbosa so high?

He had a string of a few good games after the Marbury trade and has

Jason Williams and Earl Watson should be higher.

1. Jason Kidd (Still the Overall Best PG)
2. Sam Cassell (Having a great year, also an excellent FG%)
3. Stephon Marbury (Great with PHX, Great with NYK, but has struggled in a few games)
4. Steve Nash (Getting his assists and even his points, even with a mostly shooting team around him)
5. Eric Snow (Another underrated very solid PG)
6. Baron Davis (Horrible FG% hurts his stock, underrated passer)
7. Steve Francis (Even in an off year, posting decent numbers, however, bad FG% and lots of TOs drops him)
8. Gary Payton (Solid PG, won't make too many mistakes)
9. Mike Bibby (Pretty Solid PG, although being on the Kings will hurts your assist numbers)
10. Andre Miller (Had inconsistency issues, but is starting to play way more solid)
11. Chauncey Billups (Decent all around PG, pretty clutch)
12. Jason Williams (Injured this season a bit, but very solid, although sometimes struggles with shooting, very underrated)
13. Jason Terry (Decent PG, although assists have dropped a little, has shooting slumps)
14. Dwyane Wade (Decent 1st year at PG, been injured a bit, and too many TO's)
15. Brent Barry (Excellent shooter, great passer, just doesn't shoot enough)

Rankings got even harder, so I stopped.

Kirk Hinrich (Good rookie PG, shot could be improved, but has seized starting PG spot from Crawford)
Raul Lopez (Excellent backup to Arroyo, can start, as shown when Arroyo was out)
TJ Ford (Great passer, lots of TOs though, can't shoot the ball)
Carlos Arroyo (Great 1st year as a starter)
Marko Jaric (Way too inconsistent and doesn't have the PG "state of mind" yet)
Earl Watson (Another very very very underrated PG, could start on many other teams)

People I took off:

Troy Hudson (Just hasn't played enough, plus being behind Cassell will drastically hurt your numbers)

Leandro Barbosa (Barely played when Marbury was there, had a few good games, doesn't really merit consideration)

Chucky Atkins (Why is he on here?)

Gilbert Arenas (Been injured way too much, would be in Top 10, if improved FG% and less TO's)

Nick Van Exel (Has been injured often this season, can't judge him)

Luke Ridnour (Played while Ray Ray was out, stopped playing when Ray Ray came back, needs more minutes)

Steve Blake (Hasn't played enough)

Anyways, these are my opinions, take them like you would take any others.

 

[Pumpkin_Escobar]

Never do any more rankings as long as your live...

1.jason kidd
2.baron davis
3.stephon marbury
4.steve francis <---He is playing like crap this year...not even top 20
5.lebron james <---Doesn't play PG that much anymore
6.sam cassell
7.mike bibby
8.steve nash
9.tony parker
10.gilbert arenas <--Barely has played
11.jason terry <---Horrible choice here
12.gary payton
13.dwayne wade
14.jason williams <---Played great when not injured; should be hugher
15.andre miller
16.nick van exel
17.chauncey billiups <---Horrible shooting %
18.brent barry <---Isn't really PG
19.kirk hinrich
20.jamal crawford <---Plays 2 now because of Hinrich
21.raul lopez <---Doesn't even start...should be lower
22.tj ford
23.carlos arroyo
24.marko jaric
25.leandro barbosa
26.steve blake
27.luke ridnour
28.chucky atkins
29.eric snow <---Top 15 if not top 10
30.earl watson
31.troy hudson <---Has he even played

There are more just didn't feel like typing

 

[NugzFan]

man dre gets no respect.

 

[KTLuvsMikeBibby]

ur a wolves fan and you put francis ahead of cassell? you must not watch that many of their games.
my top 10:
1. baron davis
2. jason kidd
3. stephon marbury
4. sam cassell
5. steve nash
6. mike bibby
7. gary payton
8. tony parker
9. jwill
10. andre miller

 

[Rockstone]

Originally posted by <b>AL9045</b>!
1. Jason Kidd (Still the Overall Best PG)
2. Sam Cassell (Having a great year, also an excellent FG%)
3. Stephon Marbury (Great with PHX, Great with NYK, but has struggled in a few games)
4. Steve Nash (Getting his assists and even his points, even with a mostly shooting team around him)
5. Eric Snow (Another underrated very solid PG)
6. Baron Davis (Horrible FG% hurts his stock, underrated passer)
7. Steve Francis (Even in an off year, posting decent numbers, however, bad FG% and lots of TOs drops him)
8. Gary Payton (Solid PG, won't make too many mistakes)
9. Mike Bibby (Pretty Solid PG, although being on the Kings will hurts your assist numbers)
10. Andre Miller (Had inconsistency issues, but is starting to play way more solid)
11. Chauncey Billups (Decent all around PG, pretty clutch)
12. Jason Williams (Injured this season a bit, but very solid, although sometimes struggles with shooting, very underrated)
13. Jason Terry (Decent PG, although assists have dropped a little, has shooting slumps)
14. Dwyane Wade (Decent 1st year at PG, been injured a bit, and too many TO's)
15. Brent Barry (Excellent shooter, great passer, just doesn't shoot enough)

Most accurate list I've seen so far. Maybe I'll get mine together some time.

 

[Cap]

Steve Francis is not a PG, let's get that much straight first. :laugh:

My top 10 list:

1. Jason Kidd
2. Sam Cassell
3. Baron Davis
4. Stephon Marbury
5. Steve Nash
6. Gary Payton
7. Chauncey Billups
8. Bobby Jackson
9. Andre Miller
10. Eric Snow

EDIT: I missed a number, haha. Put Eric Snow there.

 

[Johnny Mac]

1. Jason Kidd - hes the man, obvious choice here

2. Baron Davis - Was going to put Cassell here, but thought about it more and I think if Baron was in the same situation as SC playing with KG, he'd probably be tearing it up as well.

3. Sam Cassell - Great shooting this season, very efficient. Making all the right plays for a winning squad. 4th quarter assassin.

4. Stephon Marbury - Could easily be as high as #1 if he played consistently as well as he could. Seems like he can light you up for 40 pts and like 6 assists one night, then the next night score 8 points and get 18 assists. Its a tribute to his ability, but also a knock on his consistency.

5. Steve Nash - 14 pts, 8 asts a game on a power house team. Mavs will only go as far as Nash takes them. He is the leader of the team IMO.

6. Mike Bibby - his assist numbers arent as high as the others, but thats because the Kings are such a good passing team and they dont rely on him to create shots for others. Him and Jackson are very effective players in the 4th quarters this year as well. They seem to hit jumper after jumper in the final minutes.

7. Gary Payton - Been the floor leader of the most hyped team in years. Added an up and down fastbreak game to the Lakers that has been to the benefit of Kobe/George/Malone. Payton needs to get comfortable in the offense though, thats kind of hard now that everyones hurt.

8. Bobby Jackson - Should be 6th man of the year, no matter how good Jamison plays. Kings have him set aside to come off the bench and give them energy. Only playing 25 minutes a game this year, but that will increase come playoff time. Plus hes always in the game in crunchtime.

9. Chauncey Billups - 18/5/4 on a top 10 team. FG% needs to come up, only shooting 38%. Shooting 43% from the 3pt line though.

10. Eric Snow - Underrated.

Hinrich, Wade, Miller all are right there at the end. Francis is a two to me.

 

[merc_cuban]

Originally posted by <b>KG4MVP2</b>!
Rankings based on performance this year
1.jason kidd
2.baron davis
3.stephon marbury
4.steve francis
5.lebron james
6.sam cassell
7.mike bibby
8.steve nash
9.tony parker
10.gilbert arenas
11.jason terry
12.gary payton
13.dwayne wade
14.jason williams
15.andre miller
16.nick van exel
17.chauncey billiups
18.brent barry
19.kirk hinrich
20.jamal crawford
21.raul lopez
22.tj ford
23.carlos arroyo
24.marko jaric
25.leandro barbosa
26.steve blake
27.luke ridnour
28.chucky atkins
29.eric snow
30.earl watson
31.troy hudson
any thoughts comments????????

you do know that nash has a triple dub this year right? Other than cassell no other pg is seeing nash. case closed