I'm in favor of signing him with a portion of the MLE because he is only 22. There is still time for improvement.
Robinson signed his deal at 25, and there was little merit to it. Robinson had only played 2 seasons, and had only averaged 7 ppg in each, nothing else.
Miles has averaged 9 ppg in each, but he can also do more. Unlike Robinson, he can play defense, and he can actually pass and rebound the basketball. Prior to this season, Paul Silas was babbling something about Miles starting at PG. He has the handle to do so (just not the passing mentality). Robinson does not have this handle. I did not hear any talk of E-Rob replacing J-Will last summer.
And unlike Robinson, Miles would probably be in the NY rotation more than just his first year. Unless you think Penny and Shandon are going to hold the fort down until they are each 35. The Knicks won't have any assets remaining that they could trade to add any other SFs (or any players, for that matter)
I think it's fairly obvious who the better player is.
I am with you on this one....We have no choice but to take low probability shots on guys with tremendous upside..It is our only option,unless you think we are good enough to win with the current squad....We have ZERO run jump athletes...I personally would do anything and everything to get Wilcox...