Professional and College Basketball Forums banner

will marvin make the all rookie team

  • yes all rookie first team

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • yes all rookie second team

    Votes: 14 45.2%
  • no

    Votes: 17 54.8%

will marvin williams make the all rookie team

750 Views 18 Replies 16 Participants Last post by  jworth
i think he's done enough to make all rookie second team if he doesn't make it is probaly becuse they expected moe out of him
  • Like
Reactions: 1
1 - 19 of 19 Posts
No to first-team.

Maybe to second team.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Chris Paul
Raymond Felton
Deron Williams
Charlie Villanueva
Andrew Bogut

Danny Granger
Luther Head
Marvin Williams
Jose Calderon
Ryan Gomes
HKF said:
Chris Paul
Raymond Felton
Deron Williams
Charlie Villanueva
Andrew Bogut

Danny Granger
Luther Head
Marvin Williams
Jose Calderon
Ryan Gomes


No Frye? Even if he's out for the rest of the season, I expect him to make the all rookie team, maybe even 1rst.


edit: And as much as I like Calderon, I don't think he will make the all rookie, since his injury he hasn't been good at all.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Frye hasn't done much for weeks. He will probably get 2nd team though.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
HKF said:
Chris Paul
Raymond Felton
Deron Williams
Charlie Villanueva
Andrew Bogut

Danny Granger
Luther Head
Marvin Williams
Jose Calderon
Ryan Gomes
Ryan Gomes? Hells yeah.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I don't think he'll get in.

The players HFK listed will probably get in with Marvin Williams being replaced by Channing Frye. No way in hell Frye gets shafted... Even Nate Robinson has had a pretty good season and may be a possibility.
basically i'd love to see all 3 toronto rookies make it, but only charlie villanueva is a lock & that's for first team. he will be runner up for rookie of the year.

graham & calderon, i dont really see making 2nd team, and i'd say for this thread..


Salim Stoudamire has a better chance to make a team then MW.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I honestly can't stand this guy. I didn't want us to draft him...I wanted Williams or Paul.

So personally, even though I'm a big Hawks guy...I hope he flops like nobodys buisness.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Marvin has only shown sparks of talent. He hasn't been consistent this season. He shouldn't have been #2 pick imo.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
He is in no way shape or form deserving of making either rookie team
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Marvin Williams is among the top 10 rookies in scoring, rebounding, blocks, and steals and that alone gives him solid consideration for second team all rookies. Williams is averaging eight points and almost five rebounds per contest, and while those numbers are far from overwhelming, this year's rookie class isn't all that strong and Williams is easliy among the 10 best.

Williams has really been the second best rookie forward this season behind Villaneuva (counting Bogut as a center), and the only thing keeping him out of all rookie first team is the fact that there is a nice crop of guards who deserve to make that lineup ahead of him. So he should be all rookie second team.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
certainly he won't make the first team.The second team?why not..
Somehow, Isiah Thomas
  • Like
Reactions: 2
jworth said:
Marvin Williams is among the top 10 rookies in scoring, rebounding, blocks, and steals and that alone gives him solid consideration for second team all rookies. Williams is averaging eight points and almost five rebounds per contest, and while those numbers are far from overwhelming, this year's rookie class isn't all that strong and Williams is easliy among the 10 best.

Williams has really been the second best rookie forward this season behind Villaneuva (counting Bogut as a center), and the only thing keeping him out of all rookie first team is the fact that there is a nice crop of guards who deserve to make that lineup ahead of him. So he should be all rookie second team.


No Granger?
Marvin has been better than I expected this year, hopefully he gets away from that horrible Hawks team then he will really be able to shine. Michael Jordan would look bad on that patheticly run, black hole of a franchise in Atlanta. They might be the worst organization in all of pro sports. At least New York is willing to spend as much money as they need.
Wow, the PG's in this draft are so much deeper than the rest. These have been 8 rookie PG's who have started games this year (Jarret Jack, Nate Robinson, Calderon, Paul, Sarunas, Felton, Deron, Head) and then Salim who I'm not sure if he's started but he's given big minutes.
Lebbron said:
Wow, the PG's in this draft are so much deeper than the rest. These have been 8 rookie PG's who have started games this year (Jarret Jack, Nate Robinson, Calderon, Paul, Sarunas, Felton, Deron, Head) and then Salim who I'm not sure if he's started but he's given big minutes.
Yup, legendary year for point guards, especially in comparison to next.
Dee-Zy said:
No Granger?
His numbers have practically been identical to Williams' numbers so it could be said that he's had a better season.
1 - 19 of 19 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top